Fishing at Sheldon Lake
2-4 hours
Moderate
Fishing at Sheldon Lake in City Park, Fort Collins, Colorado, offers an accessible and serene experience for anglers of all levels. With its central location and calm atmosphere, Sheldon Lake is a go-to spot for families, beginners, and experienced fishing enthusiasts looking to unwind. A haven for both recreation and wildlife, the lake showcases an ideal setting for those keen on immersing themselves in Fort Collins’ outdoor opportunities.
Sheldon Lake features a variety of fish, including bluegill, largemouth bass, channel catfish, and common carp. These species make the lake a versatile fishing spot, accommodating everything from fly-fishing enthusiasts to bait anglers. The warm-water fish population ensures great success during the summer and early fall months.
Prime Fishing Spots The north and east shores of Sheldon Lake are particularly popular for fishing. With open spaces and shaded areas, anglers can comfortably set up a spot. The park management has also installed fishing piers, which are perfect for anyone wanting a more stable platform to cast their line. These piers provide ease of access, including wheelchair accessibility.
No Wake Zone Boats without gas-powered motors are allowed on Sheldon Lake, but its “No Wake” status ensures that fishing remains undisturbed by noise or waves. Kayaks and small paddle boats are common, and anglers using these often find success when casting lines around the lake's center or near submerged vegetation edges.
Established within the larger City Park, Sheldon Lake has been a staple of the Fort Collins community for decades. While it offers a quiet retreat, it’s also an active hub for locals. Ducks and geese frequently gather here, and, occasionally, herons can be spotted. This wildlife presence makes fishing not only engaging but also scenic, particularly at sunrise.
Best Times to Visit: Early mornings or late afternoons are ideal, as fish are more active and temperatures cooler.
What to Bring: A valid Colorado fishing license, sunscreen, a cooler, and your preferred tackle.
Directions: From downtown Fort Collins, head west on Mulberry Street for approximately 2 miles. City Park and Sheldon Lake will be on your right.
Great destination! Enjoyed the open trail and peaceful outdoor atmosphere.
Beautiful place.
Great destination! Enjoyed the open trail and peaceful outdoor atmosphere.
Beautiful lake, geese are loud
Great destination! Enjoyed the open trail and peaceful outdoor atmosphere.
7.00 miEasyEnjoy fishing at Sheldon Lake in City Park, Fort Collins, CO. This easy-access lake offers a family-friendly atmosphere with catchable bluegill and bass. The area is wheelchair accessible, vibrant with wildlife and best visited in summer and fall.
7.02.87 miModerateExplore the 1.3-mile A Trail in Maxwell Natural Area near Fort Collins, CO. With a moderate difficulty, this hike offers scenic views of Horsetooth Reservoir and local wildlife. Ideal for beginners, families, and CSU fans.
7.52.87 miExplore Rotary Park at Horsetooth Reservoir near Fort Collins, CO for a mix of classic bouldering problems and scenic views. Suitable for climbers of all levels, this popular area is just a 20-minute drive from town. Best visited in spring or fall to avoid crowds.
0.34 miPod 3 is a purpose-built lodging option at Sky Ranch Lutheran Camp that accommodates up to 60 guests with sleeping pods, private restrooms, and a large meeting area — this guide orients planners and visitors to what the venue provides.
0.53 miA 1–5 night lodge stay at Sky Ranch Lutheran Camp in Bellvue offering direct access to Colorado’s Rocky Mountain landscape and clear check-in/check-out times for planning.
0.56 miA practical guide to Thunder — one of 11 rustic cabins at Sky Ranch, each with a private deck and bunk-bed sleeping for 10–12, heated for winter stays.
1.10 miA three-hour Hop Cart tour that visits Old Elk, CopperMuse, Gnebriated Gnome and Mobb Mountain for guided tastings of whiskey, vodka, gin and rum—this guide lays out the route, what to expect, and who can join.
1.10 miA relaxed, comfortable e-bike rental on Pedego’s most popular model — available in 2, 3, 4 or 8-hour blocks and supplied with helmets and locks.
1.10 miA short-guide to renting the Stretch Cargo e-bike in Ft. Collins — roomy enough for one or two small children, available in 2-, 3-, 4- or 8-hour blocks with helmets and locks included.